Colombia’s glass part empty? Finance minister stirs investor fear

Colombia's glass half empty? Finance minister stirs investor concern

By means of Helen Murphy and Nelson Bocanegra

BOGOTA (Reuters) – For some, Colombian Finance Minister Alberto Carrasquilla’s stark warnings of the “huge demanding situations” going through executive funds are a calculated gamble to push via unpopular tax reforms.

His tone ruffled feathers when he took place of work in August as a part of new President Alvaro Duque’s centre-right cupboard.

However many buyers are rising involved that his review might come to fruition – hanging the country’s funding grade credit standing in danger – until deep structural adjustments are made.

His predecessor, Mauricio Cardenas, left pronouncing the worst was once over for Latin The united states’s fourth-largest economic system and executive funds have been not off course as oil costs stepped forward.

Carrasquilla, who served as finance minister between 2003 and 2007 below former President Alvaro Uribe, poured chilly water on that. He stated subsequent 12 months’s finances was once underfunded by way of about 25 trillion pesos (6.24 billion kilos) – 10 % of the 258 trillion pesos finances.

A change and bond sale have halved that to $five billion.

“You’ll be able to at all times say the glass is part empty, part complete,” stated Samar Maziad, analyst at Moody’s.

“There are issues that if left unaddressed may result in a weaker fiscal image so it is useful to get forward of those problems … It is (additionally) essential to reassure buyers in regards to the power of the fiscal reforms.”

Moody’s revised its the outlook on its Baa2 ranking to damaging from solid in February. That adopted a S&P’s determination to downgrade Colombia’s credit standing in December to BBB-, one notch above junk, bringing up considerations over the federal government’s talent to adequately reduce the fiscal deficit.

Duque is urgent forward with a tax reform – referred to as the financing legislation and more likely to be introduced this week – that may cut back industry taxes and pile extra at the center magnificence.

Some say Carrasquilla’s damaging review is warranted, and his forthright warnings could also be a way to lay the groundwork for reforms, now not simply to taxation but in addition Colombia’s creaking and unsustainable pension device – which the federal government funds to the song of $12 billion once a year.

“He is highlighting the fiscal demanding situations. Truthfully, I do not believe he is over-reacting; the fiscal demanding situations are there,” stated Manuel Orozco, a S&P analyst in Mexico.


Beneath multi-year objectives, the federal government will have to decrease the fiscal deficit to at least one.five % of GDP by way of 2022 from 3.1 % in 2018.

Duque’s executive is worried to steer clear of shedding Colombia’s funding grade. Slipping to a junk ranking would bar many international buyers from preserving Colombia’s debt and pressure up borrowing prices when cash is had to fund post-conflict wishes following an finish of the struggle with the Innovative Armed Forces of Colombia in addition to well being and schooling prices.

Alternatively, many economists, together with former finance ministry and central financial institution officers, informed Reuters they have been baffled by way of Carrasquilla’s stark quantity, and a few complained he didn’t give an explanation for it sufficiently.

“It is a little complicated and now not simple to know the determine and the place it comes from,” stated Camila Perez of financial think-tank Fedesarrollo, even though she agreed the former executive have been too positive in its earnings and spending forecasts.

However “to mention there is a fiscal deficit of two.four % of GDP isn’t like pronouncing that the finances is below financed by way of (eight billion),” she added.

A senior finance ministry respectable informed Reuters that the shortfall comes from social systems that the brand new executive needs however that have been now not integrated within the finances despatched to congress by way of Cardenas in July.

The backdrop of a rout in rising markets is including to a few buyers’ nerves. Whilst Colombia’s $324 billion economic system has now not suffered like Turkey and Argentina, observers worry that jittery buyers may take flight if the uncertainty worsens.

Native Treasury bonds (TES) maturing in 2024 have greater than doubled their intra-day volatility and yields have risen to about 6.five % from 6.185 % ahead of Carrasquilla took place of work on Aug 7.

“The principle possibility is that, as an example, the financing legislation does not cross and the minister’s fairly alarmist communique scares the marketplace and so they get started promoting TES, which previously how been gradual,” stated Sergio Olarte, leader economist at BTG Pactual, one of the vital marketplace makers that buys home debt.


The overall phrases of the tax reform have now not but been introduced to congress, developing time force on getting it authorized by way of a divided legislature ahead of year-end.

Dialogue additionally comes amid a push by way of the left-wing opposition in congress for Carrasquilla’s resignation for alleged corruption all over his first stint as minister, which has not on time passage of the invoice.

Whilst upbeat on Colombia in most cases, buyers like Jacob Jensen, senior portfolio supervisor at International Evolution in Denmark, which dangle Colombia’s native and in a foreign country bonds, additionally concern tax reform might be diluted.

“For the present management it may well be tricky to enforce reforms with a congress extra divided than in the past,” Jensen stated.

Andres Lozano, who is helping organize $11 billion at Colfondos pension fund, stated Colombia’s basics stay sure: Inflation is below keep an eye on, rates of interest are low, the economic system is getting better and the brand new executive is pro-market.

However he stressed out that uncertainty was once now not useful.

“With the exception of dwelling with rising marketplace uncertainty because of the Fed charge upward push, it isn’t excellent so as to add every other aspect of uncertainty by way of failing to provide an explanation for plans obviously,” stated Lozano, whose fund holds about 30 % in TES.

A part of the problem is that the media-shy Carrasquilla has didn’t keep up a correspondence smartly with the marketplace, buyers say. He has refrained from newshounds and held simply two information meetings since taking place of work.

“Cardenas was once very open to speak with buyers, with the clicking, with analysts,” stated BTG Pactual’s Olarte. “Now there is general silence.”

(Reporting by way of Helen Murphy and Nelson Bocanegra; Modifying by way of Daniel Flynn and Cynthia Osterman)

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.